Cumberland Times-News


October 17, 2013


Court: Public has right to see police records

The public has a right to know how police police themselves. That is the crux of an issue now being deliberated by the West Virginia Supreme Court.

The issue surfaced when the Charleston Gazette filed a lawsuit because it was denied information about abuse and misconduct on the part of state police officers. The records were denied by the police agency’s Professional Standards division, which handles internal investigations.

On Tuesday, the state’s high court heard arguments in the case and said it would issue a ruling later this year. Supreme Court Justice Margaret Workman said Tuesday she found it “troubling” the information isn’t released, especially after investigations are concluded. “If the public doesn’t have the right to know anything about any of these complaints — that just seems like it’s not in the spirit of the Freedom of Information Act,” Workman said.

Virginia Lanham, attorney for the State Police, disagreed, arguing that opening the files would hurt the scope of the investigation. Sean McGinley, attorney for the Gazette, said there  should be no difference between troopers, who have the files closed, and doctors and lawyers who have complaints against them open for the public to see.

Among other concerns raised during Tuesday’s court arguments were those dealing with an officer’s medial or psychiatric issues and whether complaints against officers could be used to “harm or embarrass” officers.

Medical records can always be redacted by the court. As for the embarrassment, that is a price that has to be paid if a police officer is found guilty of violating the public’s trust.

Keeping records secret only undermines the public’s confidence in law enforcement agencies.

Only by following an open and transparent policy can that public trust be maintained.


Text Only
  • C-minus grade C-minus grade

    If a survey conducted by and the Kaufman Foundation is an accurate portrayal, Maryland has a long way to go to become a business-friendly state.

    July 24, 2014 1 Photo

  • Big loophole Big loophole

    How ironic — and how sad — that the Potomac Highlands Airport Authority plans a closed executive session to discuss the open meetings law.

    July 23, 2014 1 Photo

  • Preposterous Preposterous

    File this one under the We Thought We’d Heard Everything category: A man who attempted the armed robbery of a pizza shop is now suing the pizzeria and the employees who tackled him and wrestled his gun away during the holdup.

    July 22, 2014 1 Photo

  • No secrets No secrets

    The idea of fracturing for natural gas makes many people anxious about potential harmful effects. For that reason alone, it is incumbent on Maryland government to require full disclosure of chemicals used in the process.

    July 21, 2014 1 Photo

  • Don’t do it. Don’t do it

    Temperatures have been moderate recently but are projected to rise to the upper 80s and low 90s later this week, so we want to remind you: Never leave children unattended in a vehicle.

    July 21, 2014 1 Photo

  • July 20, 1969 July 20, 1969

    When Apollo 11 landed on the moon 45 years ago today, it was until that time the mostwatched television programming in history.

    July 20, 2014 1 Photo

  • Stopgap

    Kicking the can down the road was one of the things American kids did to pass the time in the old days, particularly if they lived in rural areas where there was little traffic to contend with.

    July 16, 2014

  • Maryland on target to meet 2025 bay restoration goals

    July 16, 2014

  • Tough luck Tough luck

    The state has for a second time declined to help Allegany County get federal flood recovery funds in the wake of the June 12 storm.

    July 15, 2014 1 Photo

  • Heard it all Heard it all

    Pesky thing, this requirement that political candidates file campaign finance reports.

    July 14, 2014 1 Photo