Cumberland Times-News

Mike Burke - Sports

September 7, 2012

Cleveland still blames Modell, but it shouldn’t

Baltimore and Cleveland are so similar to one another and, for various reasons — in civics, culture, demographics and sports — are often linked to one another. Certainly Art Modell, who died Thursday morning at the age of 87, is a major reason why.

On Nov. 6, 1995, he announced he would do the unthinkable and move his Cleveland Browns to Baltimore, which had been without an NFL team for 12 seasons, and the Maryland city rejoiced — to a degree, because to this day nobody better understands how Cleveland still feels about losing its beloved original Browns than does Baltimore, which had to live through the Colts packing up and moving to Indianapolis in March of 1984.

Sure, there is another version of the Cleveland Browns (sans Ozzie Newsome and Ray Lewis) playing their games in a new state-of-the art stadium, and that’s because Modell left the Browns colors and history in Cleveland — a fate not accorded to Baltimore when the Colts left — and because, when Cleveland attempted to block the move in court, it ended up settling for $12 million from Modell and the promise from the league of a new team that would be the Browns and adopt its records and history.

The NFL even subsidized the construction of the city's new stadium on a loan it collected from the new Browns franchise, prompting Modell to say, “If I had gotten half of that, I would still be in Cleveland.”

(By the way, the original owner of the new Browns was Modell’s friend Al Lerner, upon whose airplane Modell signed the deal to move the team from Cleveland to Baltimore.)

Still, Modell, a man who should be in the Pro Football Hall of Fame for his pioneering efforts that made the NFL the most powerful sports entity in the history of the world, is not a Hall of Famer. In fact, even on the day of his death, he is vilified in Cleveland just as the late Baltimore Colts owner Robert Irsay, who should not be a Hall of Famer, still is in Baltimore.

Unlike Irsay, though, the last thing Modell wanted to do was move his franchise out of Cleveland, a city he had grown to love and help in countless ways. His philanthropy in Cleveland alone is legendary, just as it is now in Baltimore. Among many other things, he raised millions for the Cleveland Clinic and helped rescue the struggling landmark Hotel Cleveland. But Modell was in debt in large part because — irony of ironies — he took over as landlord of Municipal Stadium, better known to the world as The Mistake By The Lake, to help prevent the baseball Cleveland Indians from leaving town.

In the meantime, a decade after putting up $65 million for the relocation and construction of the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame, Cleveland taxpayers paid to build the Great Lakes Science Center and new downtown sports palaces for the Indians and the NBA Cavaliers, but not one for one of the most famous sports franchises in the world and, certainly, the most beloved one in Cleveland, the NFL Browns.

The truth of the matter is Cleveland turned its back on Modell and left him no choice but to leave, just as the Irsay family will say of Baltimore and the state of Maryland. The Indians, Modell’s biggest tenant of Municipal Stadium, now had its own facility, as did the Cavaliers, and Modell was left with a crumbling non-revenue producing venue and the prospect of going broke.

He refused to sell the team to Lerner, he said, wishing instead to leave it to his family, which reaped the benefits of that ownership when the Ravens were sold to Steven Bisciotti. How can you blame a man for that? How can you blame him for wanting to keep what he built for the sake of his family? How can you not blame the civic leaders of Cleveland for turning their backs on a person who did all he could do for the betterment and prosperity of their city?

Enter the weasel NFL commissioner at the time, Paul Tagliabue, former Washington Redskins season-ticket holder, who was so far in with then-Redskins owner Jack Kent Cooke, he saw to Jacksonville receiving an NFL expansion team when Baltimore’s bid was clearly the best on the table. Thus, after he snidely remarked that Baltimore should use the expansion money it raised to “build another museum,” the gloves came off, and Baltimore and the state of Maryland, which had played by all of the NFL’s rules in pursuing an expansion team, only to be dirtied upon by the NFL, actively pursued, then landed the original Browns.

On the emotional surface, it is understandable why Cleveland fans so loathe the late Art Modell, and why the Cleveland writer who has a vote for the Pro Football Hall of Fame has successfully kept Modell out of the Hall of Fame. But to truly understand why Ozzie Newsome, Ray Lewis and the rest of the Baltimore Ravens are not the Cleveland Browns, the people of Cleveland and Ohio need look no further than their own municipal leaders from the time, and to the late Jack Kent Cooke’s boy, Paul Tagliabue.

Mike Burke is sports editor of the Cumberland Times-News. Write to him at

Text Only
Mike Burke - Sports
  • Terps need to move and move quickly

    The good news is Maryland will never have to play another basketball game in the Atlantic Coast Conference. Goodbye, good riddance, sayonara, smell ya, no more of you, stay classy, we won’t let the door hit us on the way out.
    Until we see you in court.

    April 13, 2014

  • Then again, he’s manager of the Yankees, and I’m not

    I went to bed confused Wednesday night, which in itself is nothing new. But having
    watched most of the Orioles-Yankees game, including the final three innings, earlier
    in the evening, then watching the late Baseball Tonight before I turned in, I was under the impression that the Yankees had won the game when I was pretty sure before watching the show that the Orioles had won.

    April 11, 2014

  • At times we all should allow for a little flex

    Other than when I was a student in the Allegany County Public Schools System, I’ve always believed the most thankless job there is — or at least one of the most thankless jobs there is — belongs to the person who ultimately hits the switch on whether or not to call off school because of the weather. You’re slammed if you do, you’re slammed if you don’t. No matter what you decide it’s no win, but, like managing a baseball team or running a bar, everybody knows they could do it.

    January 11, 2014

  • A treasured member of the family of baseball

    When a former professional football player from our past dies, he is most often remembered as being one tough son of a gun, or a wonderful runner or pass catcher, or as a brilliant quarterback.

    January 10, 2014

  • Bob Giffin believed in the goodness of us all

    The first time the Giffin family exploded onto my radar was at a Fort Hill basketball game years ago in the old Fort Hill gym. Believe it was a City game, which meant the place was packed, the walls were sweating and the smell of popcorn permeated the atmosphere. And through it all marched the family Giffin in perfect formation, tallest in the front, shortest in the back, led by father Lew, mother Donna, oldest son Bob, second son Tom, third son Donnie and fourth son Johnnie.

    December 28, 2013

  • Redskins do that voodoo that they do so well

    This time last year the Washington Redskins were in the midst of a seven-game winning streak on their way to the NFC East title. Mike Shanahan was being hailed as the perfect football presence the franchise had sorely needed for so long. Quarterback Robert Griffin III in the sprint option was being hailed as the single greatest invention since the wheel, and beleaguered Daniel Snyder, the little owner who couldn’t, was being hailed for not even trying as he allowed his two-time Super Bowl winning coach and lord of all things football to pull the strings on all things football.

    December 13, 2013

  • Fort Hill’s approach is all-inclusive

    After Fort Hill opened everybody’s eyes last season in what was supposed to be a rebuilding year (*1), it was a pretty sure bet that the Sentinels, given all of their returning resources, would be making a run for the state championship this year (*2).

    December 6, 2013

  • What resource will the O’s allocate next?

    In November 1993, Dan Duquette, then the general manager of the Montreal Expos, traded second baseman Delino DeShields to the Los Angeles Dodgers for a young pitcher by the name of Pedro Martinez. According to a story in last Sunday’s New York Times, upon completing the deal, Duquette, now general manager of the Baltimore Orioles, told Neal Huntington, then a member of the Expos front office and now the general manager of the Pittsburgh Pirates, “This trade is going to be hated in Montreal.”

    December 4, 2013

  • No month of Sundays this Friday

    With Fort Hill comfortably in control Friday night in its eventual 46-7 1A West Region semifinal victory over Manchester Valley, and with score updates from the other semifinal pouring in from nearby Washington County, Greenway Avenue Stadium was abuzz, for the unthinkable was about to take place — Fort Hill was going to play Hancock.

    November 16, 2013

  • Mike Burke Ty Johnson works hard, and makes it look easy

    Any summer day you might go to Greenway Avenue Stadium to get a little exercise you are likely to see any number of high school athletes there working out — football players, soccer players, basketball players, any kind of player you might want to think of.

    November 9, 2013 1 Photo