Cumberland Times-News

Opinion

November 30, 2013

Gas reserves overestimated

Thank you for your lengthy treatment last weekend of recent events in Cumberland dealing with fracking (“Rally rejects fracking, gas export terminal,” “Natural gas remains good energy option, state’s petroleum group leader says,” Nov. 24 Times-News, Page 1).

It is important, however, to note that Drew Cobbs and the American Petroleum Institute continue to use out-dated estimates of the total gas reserve in Maryland, thus over-estimating the industry’s potential economic impact.

Not only did CitizenShale point this out in a report to the Maryland legislature two years ago (http://citizenshale

.org/2012/03/rebuttal-to-recent-industry-claims-by-sage-policy-institute/), and not only did a well-respected economist say the same thing last year (http://citizenshale.org/2013/01/fracking-boom-or-bust-for-maryland/ — click for pdf), but, most importantly, the official economic analysis for the Governor’s Commission also adopts the reserve estimate based on federal geologists’ research — the same one used by CitizenShale.

It’s obvious why Mr. Cobbs would continue using the inflated numbers. But even though the Times-News reporter showed no awareness, readers would do well to see the exaggerations for what they are.

Additionally, there’s a pattern here among industry groups nationwide: https://pennbpc.org/sites/pennbpc.org/files/MSSRC-Employment-Impact-Press-Release-Final.pdf

Finally, in your article, Mr. Cobbs is reported to have said that all fracking pollution incidents were surface spills, and that studies have not found water contamination from fracking — untrue.

Literally scores of suits related to water contamination have been settled nationally (though an exact number is nearly impossible to document since there is no centralized reporting requirement).

To cite prominent examples: Pennsylvania regulators, in a press release dated May 17, 2011, announced a $900,000 fine against Chesapeake Energy for “improper well casing and cementing” that “contaminated 16 families’ drinking water supplies” in Bradford County, Pa.

The case ended with Chesapeake paying $1.6 million to the family of Jared McMicken and two other families forced to abandon their homes. “With what they went through,” said their attorney, “you couldn’t pay them enough. But this is enough to get them out and into new homes.” (http://stateimpact.npr.org/pennsylvania/2012/06/21/chesapeake-to-pay-1-6-million-for-contaminating-water-wells-in-bradford-county/).

The McMickens, noted other reports, joined the “growing ranks of fracking refugees.” (http://protectingourwaters.

wordpress.com/2012/06/25/impacted-families-settle-with-gas-giant-for-1-6m-without-gag-order/)

Three years into this debate in our state, Mr. Cobbs persists in overestimating the gas reserve, jobs, and potential benefits while disregarding the impacts on American citizens. This is the industry he insists will be good for western Maryland?

(I am the citizens representative on the Governor’s Commission, though my comments do not represent the commission’s position.)

Paul Roberts

Friendsville

1
Text Only
Opinion
  • No secrets No secrets

    The idea of fracturing for natural gas makes many people anxious about potential harmful effects. For that reason alone, it is incumbent on Maryland government to require full disclosure of chemicals used in the process.

    July 21, 2014 1 Photo

  • Remember, we’re not immune to extinction

    I’d like to pose a theoretical scenario to Cal Thomas.

    If a medical specialist said, “Cal, you’ve got a serious physical problem. Do nothing and you’ll die soon. Follow my prescription, which involves certain life-style changes, and there’s a good probability you’ll live, even if your life may be a bit more constrained than now.”

    July 21, 2014

  • America has three branches of government for good reasons

    “Mikulski Calls for Continued Action to Protect Women's Health Following Dangerous Supreme Court Decision” is the heading you will find on Sen. Barbara Mikulski’s website.

    July 21, 2014

  • Tell legislators to do what is right for America’s vets

    Without our veterans and those who made the ultimate sacrifice, where would America be today? It is anyone’s guess, however certainly not the Freedom and Liberty we enjoy.

    July 18, 2014

  • Opposition and inclusion understood

    Those of you who have been here before know how I feel about the late great Len Bias, who I will remember foremost as Leonard Bias, the polite, spindly Bambi-eyed kid from Hyattsville’s Northwestern High School, who could throw a dunk through the floor, yet had the most beautiful jump shot I have ever seen.

    July 17, 2014

  • Move over Move over

    Have you noticed, in your travels, that the front end of a police cruiser usually protrudes a bit more than you would expect when the officer has it parked behind another vehicle on the side of the road?

    July 17, 2014 1 Photo

  • Use local workers in building new Baltimore Pike travel stop

    As a delegate to the Maryland General Assembly representing Allegany County, and specifically the City of Cumberland, I welcome you to our community as you prepare to construct a Love’s Travel Stop at the above referenced location (on Baltimore Pike).

    July 17, 2014

  • Northern Garrett Rescue Squad raising funds, seeks members

    The Northern Garrett County Rescue Squad recently conducted several fund raising events to raise funds for new Lifepak 15’s, which are EKG monitors with AED / defibrillator.

    July 16, 2014

  • Maryland on target to meet 2025 bay restoration goals

    July 16, 2014

  • Further proof you should never bet on baseball

    Had you known in March that ...

    July 16, 2014