Cumberland Times-News

Local Sports

November 13, 2012

Rams-49ers tie likely not enough to alter NFL rule

When St. Louis and San Francisco couldn’t produce a winner during 75 minutes of play, the complaints came from all corners of the NFL.

Tie games, after all, aren’t much fun for the fans or the players, who finish just as unsatisfied as anyone else.

“I never had to think about it until now, and I sure don’t like it,” Rams defensive end Chris Long said. “I think everybody on the field would have liked to have gone back out and just settled it, but that’s where we are. That’s the rule right now, so it is what it is.”

The Rams-49ers game Sunday finished at 24-all, the first tie in four years and only the fifth since 1990. So the rule right now that limits regular-season overtime to one period is likely to stay the same for a while.

“It’s an occasional event. There is no real concern we need to change the system,” said NFL executive vice president of football operations Ray Anderson, who happened to attend Sunday’s game in San Francisco and was also present for the Atlanta-Pittsburgh draw in 2002. The other recent occurrence was Nov. 16, 2008, when Philadelphia and Cincinnati played at 13 apiece.

Eagles quarterback Donovan McNabb infamously acknowledged afterward he was unaware tie games were still possible. San Francisco safety Dashon Goldson said the same Sunday.

“When I saw both sides walking onto the field, I was like, ‘Where’s everybody going?’” Goldson said. “Did somebody quit? Forfeit?”

Goldson, for the record, knew about the new wrinkle that now gives one team the chance to match if the other team gets the ball first in overtime and makes a field goal. (Touchdowns still immediately end the game.)

“But I didn’t know there wouldn’t be a second overtime if nobody scored,” Goldson said.

Now he does, due to a rare sequence of events during the extra period that kept the two teams even.

The Rams had an 80-yard pass on the first play negated by an illegal formation penalty. Then stalwart David Akers missed a 41-yard field goal for the 49ers. Rams kicker Greg Zuerlein made one from 53 yards, but that didn’t count because of a delay-of-game call. His next attempt from 58 yards was wide right.

By then, the anticlimactic ending seemed inevitable.

“Ties just don’t seem to make sense in football,” said Bengals left tackle Andrew Whitworth, who played in that previous draw in 2008. “There’s too much effort, too much sacrifice that goes into this game to end in a tie, that’s for sure.”

The 49ers (6-2-1) now have a hard-to-figure-out lead on the Seahawks (6-4) in the NFC West, which makes Sunday’s outcome all the more maddening.

“A division game? Oh, wow. I guess that could make it interesting at the end of the year,” Broncos wide receiver Eric Decker said.

Overtime was introduced at the college level in 1996, and there the teams trade possessions from the 25-yard line until there’s a winner. But the time when ties were permitted below the NFL was so long ago that current players never experienced that.

Denver safety Rahim Moore dug deep in his memory bank to Pop Warner ball to recall one.

“I believe we went triple overtime and we ended up winning and I don’t remember how it all went down,” Moore said. “It was like the 90s, so I forget. Also, I would say it was in the rain.”

Even the NHL has abolished ties, using a penalty shot competition after scoreless overtimes in a regular season game with mixed reviews. (Imagine the NFL switching to a punt-pass-kick contest to settle the score!)

“I would’ve loved to see a shootout,” Seattle coach Pete Carroll said, joking. “A couple of guys firing the ball at the goal posts. Anything to settle the thing.”

Uh, don’t count on that.

Anderson said the NFL’s competition committee will consider the overtime rules annually, but in a league where injuries are common the likelihood of a change is slim.

“To have these guys going into an additional overtime period or more, we would be taking on some risk we don’t think is prudent to take on,” Anderson said.

The NFL Players Association didn’t respond to a request for comment.

Another factor working against a change is game quality. With the promise of endless overtimes, if necessary to determine a winner, teams could be tempted to play conservatively down the stretch and bog a contest down in safe runs and punts.

There’s also the stake the television networks have in this multi-billion-dollar business to consider. CBS and Fox already have to push back lucrative Sunday night shows if games run long during the afternoon. The possibility — even if it’s an improbability — of a three-overtime game, then, is not ideal for them even though they’d undoubtedly keep fans glued to their sets for more time in that scenario.

Anderson said the NFL has not sought opinion from the networks on the potential of a format switch, though he said of squeezed programming, “I am sure those are legitimate concerns.”

Anderson said player health and safety is the driver of such discussions.

NBC’s “Sunday Night Football” producer Fred Gaudelli said he didn’t see the need for a change because of the rarity of ties and echoed Anderson’s concern of greater injury risk with longer games.

But, Gaudelli said, “from a TV perspective, I don’t know what the downside would be.”

1
Text Only
Local Sports
  • Leydig lifts Casselman Valley over Moose, 6-5

    Lance Leydig scored on a bases loaded suicide squeeze attempt in the bottom of the eighth inning to give Casselman Valley the early advantage over the Moose by winning game one of the best-of-three series 6-5 Monday evening.

    July 22, 2014

  • Sports Calendar - 07/23/2014

    July 22, 2014

  • CEO: Rivers to quit Clippers if Sterling stays CEO: Rivers to quit Clippers if Sterling stays

    The interim CEO of the Los Angeles Clippers testified Tuesday that coach Doc Rivers told him he will quit if Donald Sterling remains the owner of the team.

    July 22, 2014 1 Photo

  • Rory McIlroy is poised to be golf’s next big thing Rory McIlroy is poised to be golf’s next big thing

    Golf has been looking for the next big star the last five years, and Rory McIlroy is the most obvious candidate.

    July 22, 2014 1 Photo

  • Pyrenees please Nibali, Rogers in Tour Stage 16 Pyrenees please Nibali, Rogers in Tour Stage 16

    The Pyrenees on Tuesday lived up to their reputation for causing ups and downs at the Tour de France: A French rider climbed in the standings, an American went down, and an Australian rebounding from an ordeal of doping suspicions won Stage 16 in a downhill breakaway.

    July 22, 2014 1 Photo

  • Sam excited about next phase of career Sam excited about next phase of career

    Now it starts to get intense for Michael Sam and the rest of the St. Louis Rams rookies.

    July 22, 2014 1 Photo

  • Lohr helps Cork’s Cars to 4-0 win

    Broc Lohr allowed one hit on the mound and had his team’s only hit at the plate as Cork’s Cars scrapped together four runs to shut out Madigan’s Auto Parts 4-0 on Monday at the Hot Stove Complex.

    July 22, 2014

  • Northside blanks Hite in opener

    Evan Rodeheaver tossed five innings of two-hit, shutout ball to allow the Northside Diamond Dogs to gain a 1-0 lead in its opening round playoff series by beating Hite Roofing 10-0 Monday at Northern High School.

    July 22, 2014

  • Titans sweep on shutouts

    Cody Ellsworth and Jacob Foreman both pitched complete-game shutouts to keep the Tri-State Titans undefeated in the Pen-Mar-WV League after sweeping the Cumberland Orioles Sunday afternoon at Bel Air Field.

    July 22, 2014

  • Sports Roundup - 07/22/2014

    July 21, 2014